Pr strategy and tactical Doctrine

ghoststorm11 · 2010-02-26, 18:15

Hey guys and gals,

I was just reading through some forums, and I would like to have as much input as possible.

I was thinking about putting together a book (more of just a long post) about Project Reality Strategical doctrine for people in the forums to use for there own knowledge.

I want to know specifically two aspects of the gameplay from you guys.

1. What strategies did you use (all the way from the tactical level to the grand strategic level)? How did they work? Which team was it used on (US, IDF, Hamas, China, Insurgents, ect...)? How much coordination did it take? What types of terrain or maps was it used on?

2. How did the players in the game respond to that order? Did it pass with flying colors, or did it flop? Could people comprehend the plan?

Even failed strategies are welcome here. Just send me what you know and would like to share.

Thanks,

-Ghoststorm11

Sorry admins. I didnt see the link to the strategies section. Could you please move it there?

Saobh · 2010-02-26, 18:32

Moved to "PR In-Game Tactics and Strategies"

But be reminded the tactics and strategies in PR are only really good for each release cycle. Small changes can have important impact on teamwork dynamic.

Shaihuluid · 2010-02-27, 07:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by ghoststorm11

Hey guys and gals,

I was just reading through some forums, and I would like to have as much input as possible.

I was thinking about putting together a book (more of just a long post) about Project Reality Strategical doctrine for people in the forums to use for there own knowledge.

I want to know specifically two aspects of the gameplay from you guys.

1. What strategies did you use (all the way from the tactical level to the grand strategic level)? How did they work? Which team was it used on (US, IDF, Hamas, China, Insurgents, ect...)? How much coordination did it take? What types of terrain or maps was it used on?

2. How did the players in the game respond to that order? Did it pass with flying colors, or did it flop? Could people comprehend the plan?

Even failed strategies are welcome here. Just send me what you know and would like to share.

Thanks,

-Ghoststorm11

Sorry admins. I didnt see the link to the strategies section. Could you please move it there?

Yeah, I was interested in making a small .pdf on tactics a while back as well, was considering emulating the "commentary" style used by one of the millitary books I posted on here some time back (https://www.realitymod.com/forum/f11...ghanistan.html). My initial intent was to play through maybe 5-6 matches with battlerecorder on and then do a debrief and show what went right/wrong during the most intense/tactical phases of them. It was a neat idea.

However, you might want to know the forums are awash in tactical guides and essays....

what I really think we need is just a compilation of all our guides into one manual instead of all over the place.

anyhow, I like the idea of making a tactical guide and would be willing to collaborate with you in publishing something if you're interested.

ghoststorm11 · 2010-03-02, 20:22

Yea, Any help would be great. I would like to have everything from IMTs (Infantry Movement techniques) to Grand Strategy.

For instance: How should two squads run bound and overwatch.

How to move down the road as a unit.

How to run different formations.

How to "pie" a corner.

How to command a tank squad.

How to use cover.

How to use the terrain.

How to use the MDMP (military Desicion making process) to formulate a master planned based on METT-TC.

Various other aspects.

The main aspect though is say for example:

Kashan 64player
Strategy Rush:
How to use INF
How to use Armor
How to use Air
Who supports whom....

Think we can do it?

Shaihuluid · 2010-03-05, 05:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by ghoststorm11

Yea, Any help would be great. I would like to have everything from IMTs (Infantry Movement techniques) to Grand Strategy.

For instance: How should two squads run bound and overwatch.

How to move down the road as a unit.

How to run different formations.

How to "pie" a corner.

How to command a tank squad.

How to use cover.

How to use the terrain.

How to use the MDMP (military Desicion making process) to formulate a master planned based on METT-TC.

Various other aspects.

The main aspect though is say for example:

Kashan 64player
Strategy Rush:
How to use INF
How to use Armor
How to use Air
Who supports whom....

Think we can do it?

Yeah, I'm all for it!

I don't know how you want to go about setting this thing up , but I would be certainly willing to contribute some articles to and proof-read/typo-check the document.

Personally, I'm interested in dealing with game-specific strategies and tactics from a pragmatic perspective. From my experience, very few true-to-life tactics work in PR, and While emphasizing real life tactical procedures can certainly be interesting, a lot of it just doesn't transfer over. Many Gaming guides fail to recognize that while games try to emulate real life, they can't possibly duplicate everything.

That said, I've got a hundred things on my plate right now. While I'd be happy to look-over and proof anything you've written, I expect to be out of action until the end of the month.

So... If you've got anything you want me to look over and give feedback to, just drop me an e-mail at --- (PM me).

For starting up, I'd suggest that we just write a few articles on what interests us, and then go about sorting them into specific categories for the finished document. However, if you had a specific format in your mind for this doecument, I'm fine with that too.

Anyhow,This sounds good. I look forward to working with you

goguapsy · 2010-03-24, 23:17

I wrote this once...

https://www.realitymod.com/forum/f10...ber-guide.html

Ignore the formations, though.

Hope I helped

Scout_03 · 2010-06-30, 05:27

Basically I find that you should try your best to guide and advise squad leaders, as well as facilitate communication. They have the best view of their current situation, but you have the best view of the big picture. And, if you can predict the hostile movements, your situation, and team, will be that much better off in the long run.

Truism · 2010-06-30, 09:06

These things all exist in readily accessible online documents. If people want them, they can find them. I don't see the value in posting this to be honest.

If you wanted to give people a crash course in the application of tactical theory, I'd be all for that though.

Bunnyman · 2010-12-21, 17:07

I think it can be useful since most poeple do not go and study military dogma and doctrine articles. Having someone that has collated material and giving hints on how to apply this to PR is a pretty good gimmick thing to bandy around the community, the more writers you get involved and the bigger the buzz around the project the more of a success it is likely to be. No disprespect to your individual knowledge but there is no shortage of personal views from armchair generals, so the more generic it is and the more you cite and apply different military ideas as well as studying various historical battles, formations, strategies, tactics etc the more popular the project will be and the more likely folks will take it seriously. I'd be up for helping.

2010-02-26, 18:15	#1
ghoststorm11 Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 102 United States of America	Pr strategy and tactical Doctrine Hey guys and gals, I was just reading through some forums, and I would like to have as much input as possible. I was thinking about putting together a book (more of just a long post) about Project Reality Strategical doctrine for people in the forums to use for there own knowledge. I want to know specifically two aspects of the gameplay from you guys. 1. What strategies did you use (all the way from the tactical level to the grand strategic level)? How did they work? Which team was it used on (US, IDF, Hamas, China, Insurgents, ect...)? How much coordination did it take? What types of terrain or maps was it used on? 2. How did the players in the game respond to that order? Did it pass with flying colors, or did it flop? Could people comprehend the plan? Even failed strategies are welcome here. Just send me what you know and would like to share. Thanks, -Ghoststorm11 Sorry admins. I didnt see the link to the strategies section. Could you please move it there?

	Last edited by ghoststorm11; 2010-02-26 at 18:20..

2010-02-26, 18:32	#2
Saobh Retired Moderator Join Date: Jan 2006 Posts: 8,125 Afghanistan	Re: Pr strategy and tactical Doctrine Moved to "PR In-Game Tactics and Strategies" But be reminded the tactics and strategies in PR are only really good for each release cycle. Small changes can have important impact on teamwork dynamic.
	The only acceptable 'Lone Wolf' you'll be allowed to play : http://www.projectaon.org/en/Main/Home

2010-03-02, 20:22	#4
ghoststorm11 Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 102 United States of America	Re: Pr strategy and tactical Doctrine Yea, Any help would be great. I would like to have everything from IMTs (Infantry Movement techniques) to Grand Strategy. For instance: How should two squads run bound and overwatch. How to move down the road as a unit. How to run different formations. How to "pie" a corner. How to command a tank squad. How to use cover. How to use the terrain. How to use the MDMP (military Desicion making process) to formulate a master planned based on METT-TC. Various other aspects. The main aspect though is say for example: Kashan 64player Strategy Rush: How to use INF How to use Armor How to use Air Who supports whom.... Think we can do it?

2010-03-24, 23:17	#6
goguapsy Join Date: Jun 2009 Posts: 3,665 United States of America Location: Sao Paulo	Re: Pr strategy and tactical Doctrine I wrote this once... https://www.realitymod.com/forum/f10...ber-guide.html Ignore the formations, though. Hope I helped

2010-06-30, 05:27	#7
Scout_03 Join Date: Jun 2009 Posts: 4 United States of America Location: Broomfield, Colorado	Re: Pr strategy and tactical Doctrine Basically I find that you should try your best to guide and advise squad leaders, as well as facilitate communication. They have the best view of their current situation, but you have the best view of the big picture. And, if you can predict the hostile movements, your situation, and team, will be that much better off in the long run.

	Last edited by Scout_03; 2010-06-30 at 05:40..

2010-06-30, 09:06	#8
Truism Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 1,181	Re: Pr strategy and tactical Doctrine These things all exist in readily accessible online documents. If people want them, they can find them. I don't see the value in posting this to be honest. If you wanted to give people a crash course in the application of tactical theory, I'd be all for that though.
Truism Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 1,181

2010-12-21, 17:07	#9
Bunnyman Join Date: Dec 2010 Posts: 31 United Kingdom Location: Salford, Manchester	Re: Pr strategy and tactical Doctrine I think it can be useful since most poeple do not go and study military dogma and doctrine articles. Having someone that has collated material and giving hints on how to apply this to PR is a pretty good gimmick thing to bandy around the community, the more writers you get involved and the bigger the buzz around the project the more of a success it is likely to be. No disprespect to your individual knowledge but there is no shortage of personal views from armchair generals, so the more generic it is and the more you cite and apply different military ideas as well as studying various historical battles, formations, strategies, tactics etc the more popular the project will be and the more likely folks will take it seriously. I'd be up for helping.