project reality header
Go Back   Project Reality Forums > PR:BF2 Mod Forums > PR:BF2 Tales from the Front > PR In-Game Tactics and Strategies > Squad Leader Tactics
28 Sep 2024, 00:00:00 (PRT)
Register Developer Blogs Members List Search Quick Links

View Poll Results: What is your squad leading style?
Authoritarian 121 33.89%
Delegation 134 37.54%
Sheep 27 7.56%
Can't be arsed to put effort in 5 1.40%
I don't squad lead 49 13.73%
other (post below!) 21 5.88%
Voters: 357. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 2010-06-23, 14:38   #1
Rudd
Retired PR Developer
Supporting Member

Rudd's Avatar
Default what's your squad leading style?

I thought it might be interesting to talk about the squad leaders as there has't been much talk of the role in a while.

how do you like to lead your squad?

authoritarian - tightly controling what your squad members are doing


delegation - assign responsibilities but trust your squadmembers to do their jobs without supervision


sheep - put a marker down and all generally go in the same direction


a happy medium?

or other?

Myself I fluctuate between authoritarian and delegation, usually depending on the skill of my squad members, I know some fantastic PR players who only achieve their full potential when I put a tight leash on them, and I know some PR players who are able to keep with the squad without any nagging. So I fluctuate But in my squad, if you don't obey, you can't stay. Lead me, follow me or get out of my way :P


Rudd is offline
Last edited by Rudd; 2010-06-23 at 14:52..
Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-24, 02:12   #2
Mongolian_dude
Retired Moderator

Mongolian_dude's Avatar
Default Re: what's your squad leading style?

I generally dont lead much, mostly because I feel I want to micro manage my men like its an RTS and have already put allot of hours in getting my guys to "Set up looking down that road, there... No, the one a 165 with the orange car! Dammit, Conrad, tie your ***ing laces!".
So that makes me Authoritarian No.1

I quite prefer the back-seat SLing these days, or a sort of NCO position. Try and square away the slackers while the SL calls the plays. I try not to tread on toes !


...mongol...

Military lawyers engaged in fierce legal action.
Mongolian_dude is offline Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-24, 03:06   #3
goguapsy
Default Re: what's your squad leading style?

When I squad lead, I like keeping a tight leash on my squad members - I feel we can achieve a better result with that. But I do my best not to be an arse. I normally say, "okay guys, lets go there through here. Let's go." This works quite effectively when...

-You are not annoying (I hope I'm not at least)
-You are in a good mood
-If a squad member screws up accidently, you forgive him. If he keeps repeating that mistakes and he's not new (other words, he is deliberately disobeying my orders, which I try to keep simple), he must be Court Martialed (the authoritarian way -- other words, kicked).
-You do not discriminate anyone because they don't have a mic. I'd take a micless teamplayer any day over a mic-ed average player...
-And, most importantly, you work as team by communicating with your team! Use that stryker support! Work in teams!

Also, I found that the best way to get any type of squad members in a squad to work as a team, besides naming your squad in a serious manner (ex. not 1337fantry or names like that, rather Infantry TW is fine, which I use most of the time, or in US Army maps, SF or Rangers), is simple: LINE-UP! This works specially well in the beginning of rounds, and will make them feel that you want each of the guys in your squad to do their best - because every single one of them matters.

These all turned out to be great squad members (line-up happened at the beginning of the round):

Name of the squad: Infantry TW!
Map: Al Basrah



Name of the squad: Infantry TW!
Map: Operation Archer



Name of the squad: Rangers
Map: Ramiel
goguapsy is offline
Last edited by goguapsy; 2011-03-05 at 02:52..
Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-24, 03:48   #4
ebevan91
Default Re: what's your squad leading style?

I have never led a squad before but alot of my squad leaders are defensive. They'd rather bunker down and dig in than go on the offensive.
ebevan91 is offline Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-24, 04:00   #5
anglomanii
Default Re: what's your squad leading style?

i role play, i say what kits i need in a squad, tell them what their role is, and i direct the basic course of action, how individuals perform their roles is up to them. if they dont perform they dont play in my squad.
anglomanii is offline Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-24, 05:44   #6
=]H[=CubCadet1972
Default Re: what's your squad leading style?

I almost exclusively lead squads. I guess I'd consider myself an authoritarian. I give my squad the kit list: One Medic, One SAW, at least one Hooker (I rely heavily on my Specialist) and the remainder of the kits are map dependent. Snipers or Marksmen are rarely allowed in my squads.

My technique:

1. My squad is my weapon, Kills are not my priority.
2. Don't rely on your squaddies to tell you what you should do next. Make a decision, and make it quick.
3. Don't discount a squaddies idea just because you are the Squad Leader.
4. Suppressive fire is your friend.
5. Don't be afraid to retreat.
6. Check your map often, and adjust what your squad is going to do on the way the round is unfolding.
7. FOB's may not score you kills, but are vital to the team.
8. Don't build FOB's for the points, build them to be useful.
9. Sometimes ignoring a target is the best course of action, sometimes the worst. Learn to know the difference.
10. You will make mistakes. Learn from them.
=]H[=CubCadet1972 is offline Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-24, 05:55   #7
Hawkeye92
Default Re: what's your squad leading style?

I don't squadlead often. Alot of the times I do, its because the role was thrust upon me (ie: original SL leaves). But when I do, I find I generally mix between Authoritarian and Delegative.

I'm more assertive when it comes to maneuvering. For example, when I want my squad to move to a certain area, I try to dictate exactly where I want them to go and by which path I want them to follow. I'm very deliberate in the movements I make when going from point A to B. The paths I take are taken for a reason. Its most often in the interest of stealth or better approach positioning when reaching our destination.

I'm more delegative and laid back when it comes to posting up in a given position. Be it for defence, capping, or when under fire, I'm much less specific when encountering enemies. I trust my squadmates more to engage contacts. I may say express how I want to position squadmates but I don't assign specific rooftops, or bushes etc as many squadleaders do. I let my squadmates choose where they feel most comfortable or where they see is the most advantageous firing position.

I also talk alot. Sometimes this can be a good thing because it encourages others to communicate more. I'm quite talkative when it comes to calling out contacts, giving situational reports, repeating orders, and even just friendly conversation. I acknowledge that sometimes I do take it too far but I do my best to make everything I put over comms relevant and helpful.

I voted other.
Hawkeye92 is offline Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-24, 06:02   #8
Pronck
Supporting Member

Pronck's Avatar
Default Re: what's your squad leading style?

Democratic style! When we are for example at the carrier in muttrah I'll make multiple plans of attack, and let all people in the squad vote, so they know if it could be though. In battle the adrenaline will take it over, and then I will only ask them to shoot, survive, kill the objective and communicate.

When I've a commander I'll follow his orders, for example at Barracuda (TG Server 23:00 GMT+1), I followed my orders of the commander, when it didn't went right as it used to be, I will fall back to my democratic style.

We are staying up!
Pronck is offline
Last edited by Pronck; 2010-06-24 at 12:10..
Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-24, 06:21   #9
ytman
Default Re: what's your squad leading style?

A mix between Delegation and Authoritarian.

If you have earned my trust and respect I delegate tasks to you. If, however, I do not trust you I will adress you directly and tell you specifically what I need and how to do it. This will frustrate me (at least very slightly) as it is a waste of my time, unless you are a new/willing to listen player, in which case I am happy to help.

If I don't respect you (I respect all players initially, as I play with them and learn thier playstyles I may earn a greater respect, lose all respect, or simply be somewhere in between) then you will be hastily kicked from my squad after I explain why. I cannot squad lead with players who lack proper teamwork ethics. This is a capital offense in my squad and is inexcusible.

I will be very specific about movements, engagement rules, and other such things that have a high risk/reward ratio. When playing more defensively/passively I delegate tasks and roles and ask for people to help build.

The only thing I'm really very Authoritarian about is when it comes to Specialized KITS. If I find a person requesting a HAT, LAT, ENGINEER, SNIPER, or MARKSMAN with out explicitly asking me (or having a damn good reason; eg. we are being attacked by a tank) I will tell them more often than not to never do it again. If they do it again and I will tell them to immediately exchange it with a Crewman Kit. If they ignore me, I ask them to leave. If they do not leave I boot them.

By joining any squad you are giving yourself over to the Squad Leader as he sees fit. His job is to keep you alive just as much as himself since that will lead to successful missions.

EDIT: This is not to say I don't ask the opinions and input of my members. I certainly do.
ytman is offline
Last edited by ytman; 2010-06-24 at 06:26..
Reply With Quote
Old 2010-06-24, 07:04   #10
dtacs
Supporting Member

dtacs's Avatar
Default Re: what's your squad leading style?

Authoritarian.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ebevan91 View Post
I have never led a squad before but alot of my squad leaders are defensive. They'd rather bunker down and dig in than go on the offensive.
Which often fails since the SL will let the members run off. Its all about obliterating and steamrolling the enemy into submission tbh, regardless of deaths. Success so far.
dtacs is offline Reply With Quote
Reply


Tags
leading, squad, style

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



All times are GMT. The time now is 03:26.